top of page

OUR TEAM

Photo of the Nikki's Custard team

OUR STORY

At Nikki’s Custard, frozen custard is more than just a treat—it’s a tradition rooted in family, community, and the joy of sharing sweet moments. Inspired by summers spent racing bikes to Midwest ice cream shops and the vibrant custard culture of Milwaukee, Nikki’s Custard brings that nostalgia to Lancaster, PA, with a modern, creative twist.​

​

Founded by Nicole (only called Nikki by her dad these days) who turned childhood love for all things sweet into a modern, family-run business, where every scoop is crafted with care and love.​​ From our family to yours, we aim to create a space that feels welcoming, fun, and inclusive for everyone.

​

We take pride in crafting our menu with care, sourcing locally, and collaborating with incredible community partners. At the heart of it all is our amazing staff—the friendly faces who make every visit special. Their dedication, creativity, and passion bring our commitment to quality and community to life, one scoop at a time.

OUR PRODUCTS

From our signature frozen custard to non-dairy soft serve, rock solids, milkshakes, and custard-inspired coffee drinks, there’s something for everyone—adults looking for a sweet escape or families making memories together.

​

Stop by our store at 1831 Oregon Pike and discover how we blend quality, taste, and community into every creation. Thank you for letting us be part of your story!

Chocolate custard in a cup being prepared for sauce

Follow us:

  • Facebook
  • Instagram

© 2025 by NIKKI'S CUSTARD®

bottom of page